From Prospect St @ S Broadway line 2 bus to Van Cortlandt Park - 242 St, line 1 subway to New York Penn Station, then train to Middletown Nj. 2 h 41 min $18. From S Broadway/Prospect Av bus to Grand Central - 42 St, subway to Times Sq - 42 St, walk to New York, NY - Port Authority, then bus to Middletown, NJ - New Monmouth Road. 3 h 3 min $27. From Yonkers drive to Middletown. 1 h 2 min $6.
Bus or train from Yonkers to Middletown?
Westchester County Bee-Line System operates a train from Yonkers to Middletown every 10 minutes. Tickets cost $3 and the journey takes 19 min. 2 other operators also service this route. Alternatively, New York City Transit (MTA) operates a bus from Yonkers to Middletown hourly. Tickets cost $2 - $7 and the journey takes 1 h 9 min. 2 other operators also service this route.