From Middletown Ny train to Frank R Lautenberg Secaucus Upper Level, train to 34 St - Penn Station, then line 2 subway to Church Av. 2 h 27 min $26. From Galleria Mall, NY bus to 42 St - Port Authority Bus Terminal, subway to Livingston St/Smith St, then bus to Flatbush Av/Church Av. 3 h 16 min $69. From Wallkill drive to Brooklyn. 1 h 30 min $9.