Rome2Rio

How to get fromToronto to Fire Islandby plane, train, bus or shuttle

Find Transport to Fire Island

See all options

There are 9 ways to get from Toronto to Fire Island by plane, train, bus, or shuttle

Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2Rio's travel planner.

  1. Fly Toronto Pearson International Airport to John F. Kennedy International Airport, train

    best
    1. Fly from Toronto Pearson International Airport (YYZ) to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)planeYYZ - JFK
    2. Take the train from Jamaica to Babylontrain
    6h 42m
    $385–1,004

  2. Bus, train via New York

    cheapest
    1. Take the bus from Toronto to New YorkbusAdt N813 / ...
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to BabylontrainBabylon Branch / ...
    14h 11m
    $86–360

  3. Bus, train

    1. Take the bus from Toronto to New York MidtownbusFlixBus N2768a / ...
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to BabylontrainBabylon Branch / ...
    12h 39m
    $92–189

  4. Train

    1. Take the train from Toronto Union Station to New York Penn StationtrainVIA Rail
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to BabylontrainBabylon Branch / ...
    16h 44m
    $90–155

  5. Fly Toronto Island Airport to Newark Liberty International Airport, train

    1. Fly from Toronto Island Airport (YTZ) to Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)planeYTZ - EWR
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Babylontrain
    7h 24m
    $145–357

  6. Fly Toronto Pearson International Airport to Laguardia Airport, train

    1. Fly from Toronto Pearson International Airport (YYZ) to Laguardia Airport (LGA)planeYYZ - LGA
    2. Take the train from Woodside to Babylontrain
    7h 18m
    $142–276

  7. Fly Toronto Pearson International Airport to Newark Liberty International Airport, train

    1. Fly from Toronto Pearson International Airport (YYZ) to Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)planeYYZ - EWR
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Babylontrain
    7h 33m
    $154–414

  8. Fly Toronto Island Airport to Laguardia Airport, train

    1. Fly from Toronto Island Airport (YTZ) to Laguardia Airport (LGA)planeYTZ - LGA
    2. Take the train from Woodside to Babylontrain
    6h 55m
    $204–626

  9. Shuttle to Buffalo Niagara International Airport, fly to John F. Kennedy International Airport, train

    1. Take a shuttle bus from Pearson International Airport Terminal 1 to Buffalo Airportshuttle
    2. Fly from Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)planeBUF - JFK
    3. Take the train from Jamaica to Babylontrain
    8h
    $184–606

Toronto to Fire Island by bus and train

Calendar26Weekly Services
Duration12h 39mAverage Duration
Ticket$92Cheapest Price
See schedules

Questions & Answers

What companies run services between Toronto, ON, Canada and Fire Island, NY, USA?

You can take a train from Toronto Union Station to Robert Moses State Park via New York Penn Station, Babylon, and Babylon LIRR in around 16h 44m.

Airlines
Train operators
Bus operators

Want to know more about travelling around United States

Rome2Rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Filled with useful and timely travel information, the guides answer all the hard questions - such as 'How do I buy a ticket?', 'Should I book online before I travel? ', 'How much should I expect to pay?', 'Do the trains and buses have Wifi?' - to help you get the most out of your next trip.

Related travel guides

Trips from Toronto

Trips to Fire Island

Popular routes