There are 2 ways to get from Middletown to Fire Island by bus or train
Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2Rio's travel planner.
Bus, train
best- Take the bus from Middletown, NJ - New Monmouth Road to New York, NY - Port Authoritybus Rt 35 to PABT
- Take the train from New York Penn Station to Babylontrain Babylon Branch / ...
4h 21m$42–68Train
cheapest- Take the train from Middletown Nj to New York Penn Stationtrain Njcl / ...
- Take the train from New York Penn Station to Babylontrain Babylon Branch / ...
4h 23m$16–45
Middletown to Fire Island by train and bus
Questions & Answers
The cheapest way to get from Middletown to Fire Island is to train which costs $15 - $50 and takes 4h 23m.
The fastest way to get from Middletown to Fire Island is to bus and train which takes 4h 21m and costs $40 - $70.
The distance between Middletown and Fire Island is 141 miles.
The best way to get from Middletown to Fire Island without a car is to bus and train which takes 4h 21m and costs $40 - $70.
It takes approximately 4h 21m to get from Middletown to Fire Island, including transfers.
There are 73+ hotels available in Fire Island.
What companies run services between Middletown, Monmouth County, NJ, USA and Fire Island, NY, USA?
You can take a train from Middletown Nj to Robert Moses State Park via New York Penn Station, Babylon, and Babylon LIRR in around 4h 23m.
- Phone
- +1-718-217-5477
- Website
- mta.info
Train from New York Penn Station to Babylon
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 15m
- Frequency
- Every 30 minutes
- Estimated price
- $10–24
- Website
- https://www.mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road
- Schedules at
- https://www.mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road/timetables
- Off-Peak
- $10–15
- Peak
- $15–24
- Phone
- +1 973-275-5555
- Website
- njtransit.com
Train from Middletown Nj to New York Penn Station
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 25m
- Frequency
- Hourly
- Estimated price
- $2–19
- Website
- https://www.njtransit.com
- Schedules at
- https://www.njtransit.com/bus-to
- Adult
- $2–19
- Phone
- +1 201-420-7000
- Website
- academybus.com
Bus from Middletown, NJ - New Monmouth Road to New York, NY - Port Authority
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 12m
- Frequency
- Once daily
- Estimated price
- $28–45
- Website
- https://academybus.com
- Schedules at
- https://academybus.com/commuter#routes-timetables
- Adult in app purchase
- $28–40
- Adult cash ticket
- $30–45
Want to know more about travelling around the world?
Rome2Rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Read our range of informative guides on popular transport routes and companies - including Best ways to travel around Australia, 10 amazing places to get away from it all in Australia, and French strikes 2018: What are my alternative transport options? - to help you get the most out of your next trip.