There are 3 ways to get from Manhattan to Fire Island Pines by subway, train or bus

Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2rio's travel planner.

Recommended option

Subway, train  •  2 h 42 min

  1. Take the subway from 5 Av/53 St to Sutphin Blvd - Archer Av - JFK Airport E
  2. Take the train from Jamaica to Sayville Montauk

$12 - $17

2 alternative options

Train, bus  •  2 h 45 min

  1. Take the train from Penn Station to Babylon Babylon / ...
  2. Take the bus from Babylon LIRR to Rollstone Avenue S40

$14 - $18

Line 3506 bus, bus  •  3 h 47 min

  1. Take the line 3506 bus from New York, Ny to Hempstead, Ny 3506 / ...
  2. Take the bus from Hempstead Transit Center to Babylon LIRR Station n72 / ...

$14 - $38

Questions & Answers

The cheapest way to get from Manhattan to Fire Island Pines is to subway and train which costs $11 - $17 and takes 2 h 42 min.

More details

The quickest way to get from Manhattan to Fire Island Pines is to subway and train which costs $11 - $17 and takes 2 h 42 min.

More details

The distance between Manhattan and Fire Island Pines is 48 miles.

It takes approximately 2 h 42 min to get from Manhattan to Fire Island Pines, including transfers.

More details

What companies run services between Manhattan, NY, USA and Fire Island Pines, NY, USA?

You can take a bus from Manhattan to Fire Island Pines via Hempstead, Ny, Hempstead Transit Center, Babylon LIRR Station, Babylon LIRR, and Rollstone Avenue in around 3 h 47 min.

Train operators
Long Island Rail Road
Website
mta.info
Train from Jamaica to Sayville
Ave. Duration
1 h 5 min
Frequency
Every 3 hours
Estimated price
$9 - $14
Schedules at
mta.info
Train from Penn Station to Babylon
Ave. Duration
1 h 4 min
Frequency
Hourly
Estimated price
$9 - $13
Schedules at
mta.info
Bus operators
Suffolk County Transit
Phone
+1 631.852.5200
Website
sct-bus.org
Bus from Babylon LIRR to Rollstone Avenue
Ave. Duration
35 min
Frequency
Every 30 minutes
Estimated price
$2
Schedules at
sct-bus.org
Greyhound USA
Rome2rio's guide to Greyhound USA
Contact Details
Phone
+1 214-849-8100/1-800-231-2222
Email
ifsr@greyhound.com
Website
greyhound.com
Bus from New York, Ny to Hempstead, Ny
Ave. Duration
1 h 10 min
Frequency
Hourly
Estimated price
$9 - $19
Website
greyhound.com
Economy
$9 - $13
Flexible
$15 - $19
Nassau Inter-County Express
Phone
+1 516 336-6600
Website
nicebus.com
Bus from Hempstead Transit Center to Babylon LIRR Station
Ave. Duration
1 h 7 min
Frequency
Hourly
Estimated price
$3
Schedules at
nicebus.com
Trailways New York
Website
trailwaysny.com
Bus from Hempstead Transit Center to Babylon
Ave. Duration
55 min
Frequency
5 times a day
Estimated price
$11 - $17
Schedules at
trailwaysny.com
Book at
trailwaysny.com

Want to know more about travelling around United States

Rome2rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Filled with useful and timely travel information, the guides answer all the hard questions - such as 'How do I buy a ticket?', 'Should I book online before I travel? ', 'How much should I expect to pay?', 'Do the trains and buses have Wifi?' - to help you get the most out of your next trip.