Rome2Rio

How to get fromBay Shore to Ithacaby train, bus, car or plane

Find Transport to Ithaca

See all options

There are 12 ways to get from Bay Shore to Ithaca by train, bus, car, or plane

Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2Rio's travel planner.

  1. Train, bus

    best
    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train Montauk Branch
    2. Take the bus from New York, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus OurBus
    6h 30m
    $31–106

  2. Train, bus via Syracuse

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Syracusetrain train
    3. Take the bus from Syracuse Bus Station to Ithacabus bus
    9h 49m
    $70–164

  3. Drive 260.8 mi

    1. Drive from Bay Shore to Ithacacar car 260.8 mi
    5h 25m
    $48–69

  4. Train to John F. Kennedy International Airport, fly to Ithaca Tompkins Regional Airport

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) to Ithaca Tompkins Regional Airport (ITH)plane plane JFK - ITH
    4h 29m
    $53–289

  5. Train, bus #2

    1. Take the train from Babylon to New York Penn Stationtrain train Babylon Branch / ...
    2. Take the bus from New York Midtown to Ithacabus bus FlixBus 2683 / ...
    7h 28m
    $42–101

  6. Train, bus #3

    1. Take the train from Babylon to New York Penn Stationtrain train Babylon Branch / ...
    2. Take the bus from New York to Ithacabus bus Adt N806
    7h 30m
    $47–166

  7. Train to John F. Kennedy International Airport, fly to Syracuse Hancock International Airport, bus

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) to Syracuse Hancock International Airport (SYR)plane plane JFK - SYR
    3. Take the bus from Syracuse Airport, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus
    5h 57m
    $103–564

  8. Train to Laguardia Airport, fly to Syracuse Hancock International Airport, bus

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from Laguardia Airport (LGA) to Syracuse Hancock International Airport (SYR)plane plane LGA - SYR
    3. Take the bus from Syracuse Airport, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus
    6h 24m
    $107–628

  9. Train to John F. Kennedy International Airport, fly to Rochester, bus

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) to Rochester (ROC)plane plane JFK - ROC
    3. Take the bus from Rochester, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus
    6h 48m
    $888–4,089

  10. Train to Newark Liberty International Airport, fly to Syracuse Hancock International Airport, bus

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) to Syracuse Hancock International Airport (SYR)plane plane EWR - SYR
    3. Take the bus from Syracuse Airport, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus
    6h 44m
    $116–569

  11. Train to Laguardia Airport, fly to Rochester, bus

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from Laguardia Airport (LGA) to Rochester (ROC)plane plane LGA - ROC
    3. Take the bus from Rochester, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus
    7h 15m
    $252–683

  12. Train to Newark Liberty International Airport, fly to Rochester, bus

    1. Take the train from Bay Shore to Jamaicatrain train
    2. Fly from Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) to Rochester (ROC)plane plane EWR - ROC
    3. Take the bus from Rochester, NY to Ithaca, NYbus bus
    7h 37m
    $211–664

Bay Shore to Ithaca by train and bus

Calendar5Weekly Services
Duration9h 49mAverage Duration
Ticket$70Cheapest Price
See schedules

Questions & Answers

What companies run services between Bay Shore, NY, USA and Ithaca, NY, USA?

There is no direct connection from Bay Shore to Ithaca. However, you can take the train to Jamaica, take the train to New York Penn Station, walk to New York, NY, then take the bus to Ithaca, NY. Alternatively, you can take a train from Bay Shore to Ithaca via Jamaica, New York Penn Station, Syracuse, and Syracuse Bus Station in around 9h 49m.

Airlines
Train operators
Bus operators

Want to know more about travelling around United States

Rome2Rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Filled with useful and timely travel information, the guides answer all the hard questions - such as 'How do I buy a ticket?', 'Should I book online before I travel? ', 'How much should I expect to pay?', 'Do the trains and buses have Wifi?' - to help you get the most out of your next trip.

Related travel guides

Trips from Bay Shore

Trips to Ithaca

Popular routes